Critical look at “green” tech

Overview: The Physical Reality Behind Digital Life

Digital technology feels instant and immaterial, a stream you open, an AI model generating text, your files syncing across devices. But every digital action is rooted in a physical, resource-dependent system. Data centers pull from regional power grids and consume enormous amounts of water for cooling. Global fiber networks and cellular towers maintain our connectivity. Devices begin as mined minerals and end as e-waste.

This guide brings together research from my Zotero library to explore the environmental cost of digital technologies and highlight where sustainable design succeeds, and where it falls short. The goal is not to frame digital life as inherently harmful, but to make the physical systems behind it visible.

The sections that follow unpack why sustainable design must consider the entire lifecycle, how streaming is a useful everyday example of invisible infrastructure, how “Green AI” seeks to make machine learning more efficient and accountable, and how policy determines what sustainability even means at scale.

Why sustainable technology matters Foundation

Digital tools feel lightweight, but they rely on vast global infrastructure. A single data center can use as much electricity as a small town and millions of gallons of water per day for cooling. Network hardware, fiber cables, marine cables, cell towers, routers, satellites, forms a physical backbone that runs constantly, even while we sleep.

Meanwhile, every device begins its life in a mine. Smartphones, laptops, and consoles require rare earth elements and metals extracted through energy-intensive processes. Once manufactured, these devices travel through global supply chains before ending up in our hands, and eventually as e-waste.

A key theme in sustainability research is that environmental impact spans the entire lifecycle of a device:

  • Extraction: mining, minerals, and energy inputs.
  • Manufacturing: assembly, semiconductors, chemicals.
  • Transport: global shipping and logistics.
  • Usage: electricity and network demand.
  • Disposal: e-waste, recycling limits.

Most consumer-facing “green” marketing highlights only the usage phase (“this device uses X% less power”). That hides the intense environmental cost of extraction, manufacturing, and disposal. A laptop that uses less power while it's on does not erase the footprint of making it, nor the short lifespans that force early replacement. Sustainable technology has to be evaluated across this full lifecycle instead of just at the “on” switch.

Streaming & everyday media habits Case study

Streaming feels effortless, click, watch, done. But behind each stream is a chain of storage servers, global delivery networks, and end-user devices all working in real time. The simplicity hides enormous underlying infrastructure.

Research in my Zotero library, including Carbon Trust and Istrate analyses, makes several things clear:

  • Resolution matters: 4K streaming isn’t just a nicer picture, it's more data pushed through every layer of the system. More data = more energy at the data center, along the network, and on the device.
  • Repeated streaming: Watching a show repeatedly via stream forces the entire system to run each time. A download localizes that energy cost instead of repeating it.
  • Transparency issues: Some platforms publish real sustainability data. Others rely on vague eco-branding without meaningful reporting about emissions or water use.

Practical questions viewers can consider:

  • Do I always need 4K? HD often provides more than enough detail.
  • Is autoplay increasing my total watch time? Turning it off gives more control.
  • Would downloading reduce repeated network demand? often yes.

Streaming is a clear example of how invisible infrastructure supports digital life, and how small changes in viewing habits can reduce system-wide demand without demanding perfection from individual users.

Green AI: potential and problems Systems in tension

Artificial intelligence feels like the most “virtual” technology, but modern machine learning requires massive computation. Training large models uses substantial electricity and cooling water, and deployed models rely on continuous global server infrastructure. This makes AI a major sustainability concern in computing today.

From my Zotero readings, three major themes define “Green AI”:

Green AI proposes a balance: design models that solve tasks effectively while minimizing resource use. But large general-purpose models still require enormous training runs and energy-intensive deployment. Smaller, task-specific models can often achieve similar results at a fraction of the environmental cost, especially when they are designed to do one thing well instead of everything at once.

At the same time, AI is not doomed to be purely wasteful or “corporate slop.” Used with different priorities, it can support sustainability itself: optimizing energy grids, helping model climate scenarios, improving public transit schedules, or giving people clearer feedback on the impact of their choices. The problem is less the idea of AI and more the incentives that drive how it is built and deployed. Right now, many large systems are shaped by ad revenue and engagement metrics rather than long-term public benefit. A more sustainable approach would prioritize transparent, smaller-scale tools built for social and environmental goals first, and profit second.

Policy, governance, and responsibility Beyond individual choices

Individual choices matter, adjusting streaming resolution, repairing devices, using efficient hardware, but meaningful sustainability depends on policy and infrastructure.

Policy influences:

Sustainable technology is not just a matter of better consumer choices; it is a structural issue. When policy supports repair, transparency, and long-lived infrastructure, individual choices add up more effectively. Without that support, people are pushed into short device lifespans, opaque platforms, and systems that externalize their environmental costs.

Done reading? Head back to the main page

This guide is part of a sustainable technology project. If you’d like to return to the landing page, use the link below.

Back to guide home